Tuesday, February 05, 2013

tasty tuesday vol 5 citrus cookies

There are some days you have failures in the kitchen. Then there are some days you have EPIC failures. This recipe for me, was an EPIC failure.



It started off beautiful. The smells and the mixing of the sugar with the orange zest.. I was pretty excited. But my excitement didn't last long. 


The recipe advised to rolls into small balls, instead I used my small scooper. I had tasted the dough at this point and to be honest wasn't thrilled. It was extremely bland. I assumed once they were baked they would come together. Especially with the glaze..glaze always makes everything better.

So they baked. She advised in her recipe to make sure they don't over-cook. But I couldn't even get them to fully bake! The first batch was in the oven 15 minutes and was still not right. The bottoms were lightly brown but they never expanded and flattened. They were still completely raw in the center.

So the second tray I took my fingers and flattened down each cookie. Hoping by doing this they would bake completely through. It actually made them worse! They didn't bake at all!! After 15 minutes it was still totally and completely raw dough on the tray!!

(this is AFTER they baked for 15 minutes!!)


While the cookies were baking (or so I thought) I made the glaze. And even that was a failure. It didn't set and nothing I was doing could get it to be the correct consistency to set up right. Everything went into the trash.

A wasted afternoon with nothing to show for it except dirty dishes and a garbage bag full of half baked, gross cookies. What a waste.

If you want to give the cookies a try I posted the original link here. Maybe you will have better luck. If you do please let me know! 

Comments (2)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
arggghhh! That would be sooo frustrating... sorry for your 'loss' Trish.. bummer, man.
This is why I leave most of the baking in our household to my guy - he likes to follow recipes and experiment enough to make sure it works each time... if possible. I wing it, fail it.. stuff my face with marshmallows! ;o)
Better luck next time!
xx
mel
needle and nest
1 reply · active 633 weeks ago
unfortunately even he wouldn't have been able to save these.. i realized after that the reason the second tray didn't cook was because the heating element died somewhere in the middle of all this. which makes sense why the first tray got to a certain point and seemed to just stay there and the second try didnt bake at all. I had no clue it died because obviously it was still hot/ warm when i was opening the door. but i dont know, they were really bland. i found my recipe for a citrus cookie that was my coworkers grammas recipe - so maybe i'll try that once my oven is fixed. part has been ordered..just waiting for it to come in- hopefully before the weekend.

xx
trisha

Post a new comment

Comments by