Monday, May 21, 2012

Market Mondays: Mashed potato stuffed bell peppers

The market was a lot of fun this weekend going with my parents. My mom wanted to stop and look at so many different vendors than K and I normally stop and look at.  My mom loved all the pottery and the soaps and candle vendors and my dad was a good sport hanging out with not one, but two extremely indecisive ladies. I picked up all my goodies and am looking forward to yummy week of market foods.






We made this recipe last week but changed it just a little bit. I think this week we are going to use our peppers from this week in a pasta dish. But this dish was really simple and delicious. 



  • 2 bell peppers
  • 2 1/2 pounds of your choice of potatoes (we used small yellow potatoes)
  • 1/2 cup of buttermilk
  • 1 teaspoon thyme
  • 3 garlic cloves, minced  (we used 1 teaspoon granulated garlic instead of raw garlic)
  • 1/4 cup shredded Parmesan cheese
  • 1/2 cup shredded Gouda cheese
  • Salt and pepper to taste
Oven preheated to 350 degrees.

1. Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil and add the potatoes. Cook until tender, just barely falling apart.
2. Strain the potatoes and add them to a large mixing bowl along with the buttermilk, garlic, thyme, parmesan cheese,  salt and pepper. 
3. Mash the potatoes, use some of the reserved water if needed. Adjust the salt and pepper to taste.
4. Cut your bell peppers and half and seed them. 
5. Stuff your bell peppers with the mashed potatoes. You want to over stuff them but you don't want the filling to be too compact.
6. Once a bell pepper half is stuffed, place it in a baking dish and top it with some of the shredded Gouda cheese. Be generous with the cheese, it's Gouda after all. You can never have too much.
7. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees, and place the baking dish full of stuffed peppers on the bottom rack. Cook until the Gouda cheese is melted and just begins to brown. The peppers should be slightly blistered

In our version, we never use water in our mashed potatoes, just lots of butter, buttermilk and salt and pepper to taste.
We also didn't have any gouda cheese to top them. I'm not a big fan of cheese, so it wasn't a huge disappointment. Plus I love mashed potatoes - so it was a win, win with me. But if you are a cheese lover- definitely add it!
Only cooking the peppers after they have been stuffed left them a tad on the crunchy side. I think if we make them again we may cook them a bit prior to stuffing them, then stuff them and cook them the rest of the way so that they will be softer.
They were super yummy, and it was actually my first time eating a pepper. (I am a super, super fussy eater - but I'm trying new things!)

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
First of all, that looks delicious. Send of all, I just read your doll-head comment on Elycia's blog. You are officially my new favourite person. That is the absolute best. I just wish I could be there the day those walls come down. The faces, the screams, it's going to be pure awesome.
And for the thought of that alone you have a new follower!!

~Nicole http://nicolescoffeeshop.blogspot.com
1 reply · active 670 weeks ago
first, welcome to my little space- its always nice to meet new (and old) people who are reading my ramblings. makes me feel like i'm not just talking to myself.

i can only imagine the looks on the faces if the walls ever were to come down! the first year we moved in the house, i took one of them on halloween and hung it from a noose on our porch. one of my friends had come over with her kids to trick or treat, her son was maybe 5 at the time, and he looked up and saw it and started screaming and crying and demanding to leave! it was perfect! hahah
Yumm! I'm usually not a fan of bell peppers, but this looks so tasty! :)

daydream frenzy
1 reply · active 670 weeks ago
ok, i am a super fussy eater. and seriously this was the first time i had ever tried a bell pepper. i tend to act like a child when it comes to food, pursing my lips, stamping my feet (haha just kidding - well maybe?) and never had to eat anything i didn't want to. but my husband eats really well and has been pushing me to eat new things. i ate (of course) all the mashed potato and then about half the pepper - it was really good, but i think i would have like the pepper better if it was a little bit softer - so he said the next time we make them he will cook those a little bit first and then cook again with the potato and they should be better. give the recipe a try - very yummy!
Stuffed peppers... with mashed potato?! I have GOT to try that. I can already picture Steve wrinkling his nose with disapproval...
1 reply · active 670 weeks ago
sarah- it was super tasty, definitely give them a try!

Post a new comment

Comments by